Creamy Potato Salad Dill

The first time I made potato salad from scratch, I was terrified of overdoing the potatoes—I'd seen too many mushy disasters at family gatherings. I remember standing over the pot, fork in hand, testing each cube the moment it started to soften, worried I was already too late. Turns out, that vigilance paid off; I learned that Yukon Golds hold their shape beautifully if you catch them at just the right moment. Now, whenever I make this creamy dill version, I think back to that nervous energy and smile knowing exactly what I'm looking for.

My neighbor challenged me to bring something to a summer potluck that wasn't boring, and this is what showed up on the table—crisp vegetables peeking through a creamy, herb-flecked coating. Someone asked for the recipe before they even finished their plate, and I realized that simple, honest potato salad done well might just be the opposite of boring.

Ingredients

• Yukon Gold or red potatoes (1.5 lbs): These waxy varieties hold their shape and create a silky texture when coated with the dressing—avoid russets, which break down too easily.
• Mayonnaise (½ cup): Use a good quality mayo; it's the creamy backbone that carries all the other flavors.
• Sour cream (¼ cup): This adds tang and lightness, balancing the richness of the mayo.
• Dijon mustard (2 tbsp): Just enough to add a subtle sharpness without overpowering the herbs.
• Apple cider vinegar (2 tbsp): A splash of acidity that brightens everything and prevents the salad from tasting heavy.
• Fresh lemon juice (1 tbsp): Brings a clean, fresh note that makes the dill shine.
• Sugar, salt, and pepper: These seem small but they're what make the dressing taste balanced and complete.
• Celery, red onion, and fresh herbs (dill, chives, parsley): The vegetables add crunch while the herbs—especially the dill—are what make this salad memorable rather than forgettable.
• Hard-boiled eggs (optional): They add protein and richness; I often include them when I'm serving this as a main-course side.

Instructions

Boil the potatoes until just tender:

Cover your cubed potatoes with cold, salted water and bring to a boil, then lower the heat and simmer for 10–12 minutes. You're looking for that moment when a fork slides through with just a tiny bit of resistance—not mushy, not hard. Drain and let them cool slightly so they absorb the dressing better.

Build the creamy dressing:

Whisk together the mayo, sour cream, mustard, vinegar, lemon juice, sugar, salt, and pepper until it's completely smooth and there are no streaks. This dressing should taste slightly bold on its own because it will mellow once mixed with the potatoes.

Fold everything together gently:

Add the cooled potatoes, vegetables, and herbs to the dressing and fold carefully, using a spatula to make sure every piece gets coated without breaking the potatoes apart. This is not the time to be aggressive.

Taste and adjust:

Always taste before refrigerating—you might need an extra pinch of salt or a squeeze more lemon juice depending on your palate.

Let it rest in the refrigerator:

Cover and chill for at least an hour so the flavors have time to meld and the potatoes fully absorb the dressing. This step makes all the difference.

Garnish and serve:

Top with a sprinkle of fresh dill and serve chilled or at room temperature, depending on how you like it.

Pin this

I'll never forget the year my cousin went vegetarian and nobody had a side dish at dinner that wasn't drowning in bacon grease. This potato salad became the star of the table, and everyone ate it regardless of diet—proof that good food speaks louder than its label.

Why Fresh Herbs Matter So Much

There's a world of difference between a potato salad made with dried dill from a jar and one where you use fresh herbs right from the market or your garden. The fresh versions are brighter, more alive, and they're what elevate this from a boring side dish into something people actually want to eat. The smell alone, when you're folding it all together, tells you something special is happening in that bowl.

Timing and Temperature Tricks

The temperature at which you serve this matters more than you might think. Some days I prefer it chilled straight from the fridge, when the dressing is thick and the vegetables are crisp. Other times, I let it sit at room temperature for 20 minutes before serving, and it feels lighter and the flavors come through differently. Both are delicious—it just depends on what else is on the table and what the weather feels like.

Make-Ahead Confidence and Storage

This is one of those recipes that actually rewards you for planning ahead. Make it the day before your gathering and it tastes better than if you'd just thrown it together that morning. The potatoes will have fully absorbed the dressing, the herbs will have infused everything with flavor, and you'll have one less thing to stress about. It keeps well covered in the refrigerator for up to three days, though I usually finish it before then.

• Store it in an airtight container and the flavors will only deepen as it sits.
• If it looks a bit dry after a day or two, a splash of lemon juice or mayo brings it back to life.
• Always taste before serving again—you might need a tiny pinch of salt as a refresher.

Pin this

Potato salad might seem simple, but it's one of those dishes that taught me how the smallest details—a perfectly cooked potato, fresh herbs, proper seasoning—add up to something that makes people happy. That's worth getting right.

Recipe FAQs

→ What type of potatoes is best for this dish?

Yukon Gold or red potatoes work best as they hold shape well and provide a creamy texture.

→ Can I make this dish ahead of time?

Yes, refrigerate for at least one hour to allow flavors to blend; it also tastes great the next day.

→ What herbs complement the flavor?

Fresh dill, chives, and parsley add brightness and an herbal aroma to the creamy potatoes.

→ Are there alternatives to mayonnaise and sour cream?

Greek yogurt can be used for a lighter, tangier dressing while maintaining creaminess.

→ How do I avoid mushy potatoes?

Cook potatoes until just fork-tender and avoid overcooking to maintain their texture.

→ Can hard-boiled eggs be omitted?

Yes, they are optional and can be excluded for a lighter, vegetarian-friendly version.